The significance of intermediate public transportation in post-COVID-19 urban transportation planning

Abstract views: 104 / PDF downloads: 60




COVID 19, public transportation, paratransit, intermediate public transportation, informal transportation, travel behaviors


The transportation system provides various land use functions in cities and plays a significant role in shaping the urban macroform, and public transportation ensures the balance between demand and supply. In situations where supply does not meet demand, then the transportation needs for mobility are not met. This situation has caused the emergence of special operators and intermediate public transportation systems to meet demand worldwide, specifically in the cities of Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America, Asia, and Eastern Europe.

Throughout the last few decades, various public transportation policies were implemented in urban areas to relieve traffic congestion, provide road security, and increase urban life quality. As a result, increasing the share of public transportation distribution and decreasing congestion costs have become possible (Small, Verhoef, and Lindsey 2007). Some public transportation policies involve the organization of intermediate public transportation systems and their adaptation to the inner-city transportation system.

However, with the World Health Organization (WHO) declaration of COVID-19 as a global pandemic on March 11, 2020, the implementation of government restrictions and lockdowns in cities all around the world resulted in sudden declines in traveling demands. Most of these declines were associated with public transportation.

By evaluating the literature published during the first wave of COVID-19 at the beginning of the spring and summer of 2020, the second wave that started in October 2020, and the third wave that pushed many countries in the spring of 2021 to re-implement lockdown prevention, this article presents a current status analysis of public transportation, particularly intermediate public transportation systems. The main findings are summarized under eight main titles: the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on public transportation and shared mobility, its effect on intermediate public transportation and regional development, its effect on passengers in the context of social concern, its effects on passengers concerning their socioeconomic status, its effect on the business and organizational structure of public transportation, its effects regarding environmental quality, technological situation, and urban planning.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Adem Erdem Erbaş, Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University / Türkiye

Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University, Faculty of Architecture, Department of Urban and Regional Planning

Pelin Alpkökin, Istanbul Technical University / Türkiye

Faculty of Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering, Division of Civil Engineering.


ADAMS, R., & MAUTNER, A. J. (1974). Metrocab: An Electrıc Cab System For Lower And Mid-Manhattan. In Proceedings Of The Third İnternational Electric Vehicle Symposium And Exposition. 19-21 February 1974. New York. New York: Electric Vehicle Council.

ANKE, J., FRANCKE, A., SCHAEFER, L. M., PETZOLDT, T. (2021). Impact Of SARS-Cov-2 On The Mobility Behaviour İn Germany. European Transport Research Review, 13(1), 10.

ANWARİ, N., TAWKİR AHMED, M., RAKİBUL ISLAM, M., HADİUZZAMAN, M., & AMİN, S. (2021). Exploring The Travel Behavior Changes Caused By The Covıd-19 Crisis: A Case Study For A Developing Country. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives, 9.

ASKİTAS, N., TATSİRAMOS, K., & VERHEYDEN, B. (2021). Estimating Worldwide Effects Of Non-Pharmaceutical İnterventions On Covıd-19 İncidence And Population Mobility Patterns Using A Multiple-Event Study. Scientific Reports, 11(1).

BASU, R., & FERREİRA, J. (2021a). Planning Car-Lite Neighborhoods: Does Bikesharing Reduce Auto-Dependence? Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 92.

BASU, R., & FERREİRA, J. (2021b). Sustainable Mobility İn Auto-Dominated Metro Boston: Challenges And Opportunities Post-COVID-19. Transport Policy, 103, 197–210.

BEHRENS, R., MCCORMİCK, D., ORERO, R., & OMMEH, M. (2017). Improving Paratransit Service: Lessons From İnter-City Matatu Cooperatives İn Kenya. Transport Policy, 53, 79–88.

BELİAEV, M., BIYIK, E., LAZAR, D. A., WANG, W. Z., SADİGH, D., & PEDARSANİ, R. (2021). Incentivizing Routing Choices For Safe And Efficient Transportation İn The Face Of The COVID-19 Pandemic. Proceedings of the ACM/IEEE 12th International Conference on Cyber-Physical Systems, 187–197.

BOHMAN, H., RYAN, J., STJERNBORG, V., & NİLSSON, D. (2021). A Study Of Changes İn Everyday Mobility During The Covid-19 Pandemic: As Perceived By People Living İn Malmö, Sweden. Transport Policy, 106, 109–119.

CAMPİSİ, T., BASBAS, S., SKOUFAS, A., AKGÜN, N., TİCALİ, D., & TESORİERE, G. (2020). The Impact Of COVID-19 Pandemic On The Resilience Of Sustainable Mobility İn Sicily. Sustainability, 12(21).

CERVERO, R., & GOLUB, A. (2007). Informal Transport: A Global Perspective. Transport Policy, 14(6), 445–457.

CHO, S.-H., & PARK, H.-C. (2021). Exploring the Behaviour Change of Crowding Impedance on Public Transit due to COVID-19 Pandemic: Before and After Comparison. Transportation Letters, 1–8.

COPPOLA, P., & DE FABİİS, F. (2021). Impacts Of İnterpersonal Distancing On-Board Trains During The COVID-19 Emergency. European Transport Research Review, 13(1), 13.

CORPUS-MENDOZA, A. N., RUİZ-SEGOVİANO, H. S., RODRÍGUEZ-CONTRERAS, S. F., YAÑEZ-DÁ-VİLA, D., & HERNÁNDEZ-GRANADOS, A. (2020). Decrease Of Mobility, Electricity Demand, And NO2 Emissions On COVID-19 Times And Their Feedback On Prevention Measures. Science of the Total Environment.

DANESH, A., VELAGA, N. R., & MA, W. (2019). User Preferences Regarding Ridesourcing And İnformal İntermediate Public Transport. CICTP 2019: Transportation in China - Connecting the World - Proceedings of the 19th COTA International Conference of Transportation Professionals, 6109–6120.

DZİSİ, E. K. J., & DEİ, O. A. (2020). Adherence To Social Distancing And Wearing Of Masks Within Public Transportation During The COVID-19 Pandemic. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives, 7.

DZİSİ, E., OBENG, D. A., & TUFFOUR, Y. A. (2021). Modifying The SERVPERF To Assess Paratransit Minibus Taxis Trotro İn Ghana And The Relevance Of Mobility-As-A-Service Features To The Service. Heliyon, 7(5).

EUNG, N., & CHOOCHARUKUL, K. (2018). Modeling Frequency Of Using İnformal Public Transport And Public Bus: A Case Study İn Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Engineering Journal, 22(3), 109–122.

FREUDENDAL-PEDERSEN, M., & KESSELRING, S. (2021). What İs The Urban Without Physical Mobilities? COVID-19-İnduced İmmobility İn The Mobile Risk Society. Mobilities, 16(1), 81–95.

GUO, Y., YU, H., ZHANG, G., & MA, D. T. (2021). Exploring The İmpacts Of Travel-İmplied Policy Factors On COVID-19 Spread Within Communities Based On Multi-Source Data İnterpretations. Health and Place, 69, 102538.

HABİB, K. N., HAWKİNS, J., SHAKİB, S., LOA, P., MASHRUR, S., DİANAT, A., WANG, K., HOSSAİN, S., & LİU, Y. (2021). Assessing The İmpacts Of COVID-19 On Urban Passenger Travel Demand İn The Greater Toronto Area: Description Of A Multi-Pronged And Multi-Staged Study With İnitial Results. Transportation Letters, 1–14.

HEROY, S., LOAİZA, I., PENTLAND, A., & O’CLERY, N. (2021). COVID-19 Policy Analysis: Labour Structure Dictates Lockdown Mobility Behaviour. Journal of the Royal Society, Interface, 18(176), 20201035.

KAMALİPOUR, H., & PEİMANİ, N. (2020). Informal Urbanism in The State Of Uncertainty: Forms Of Informality And Urban Health Emergencies. Urban Design International, 1–13.

LEİVA, G. DE C., SATHLER, D., & FİLHO, R. D. O. (2020). Urban Structure And Population Mobility: Implications For Social Distance And Dissemination Of Covid-19. Revista Brasileira de Estudos de Populacao, 37, 1–22.

LUAN, S., YANG, Q., JİANG, Z., & WANG, W. (2021). Exploring The İmpact Of COVID-19 On İndividual’s Travel Mode Choice İn China. Transport Policy, 106, 271–280.

MOLLOY, J., SCHATZMANN, T., SCHOEMAN, B., TCHERVENKOV, C., HİNTERMANN, B., & AXHAUSEN, K. W. (2021). Observed İmpacts Of The Covid-19 First Wave On Travel Behaviour İn Switzerland Based On A Large GPS Panel. Transport Policy, 104, 43–51.

MORACİ, F., ERRİGO, M. F., FAZİA, C., CAMPİSİ, T., & CASTELLİ, F. (2020). Cities Under Pressure: Strategies And Tools To Face Climate Change And Pandemic. Sustainability (Switzerland), 12(18).

ORSKİ, C. K. (1975). Paratransit: The Coming Of Age Of A Transportation Concept. Transportation, 4(4), 329–334.

OZBİLEN, B., WANG, K., & AKAR, G. (2021). Revisiting The İmpacts Of Virtual Mobility On Travel Behavior: An Exploration Of Daily Travel Time Expenditures. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 145, 49–62.

PARDO, C. F., ZAPATA-BEDOYA, S., RAMİREZ-VARELA, A., RAMİREZ-CORRALES, D., ESPİNOSA-OVİEDO, J. J., HİDALGO, D., ROJAS, N., GONZÁ-LEZ-URİBE, C., GARCÍA, J. D., & CUCUNUBÁ, Z. M. (2021). COVID-19 And Public Transport: An Overview And Recommendations Applicable To Latin America. In Infectio (Vol. 25, Issue 3, pp. 182–188). Asociacion Colombiana de Infectologia.

ROOS, D., & ALSCHULER, D. (1975). Paratransit - Existing İssues And Future Directions. Transportation, 4(4), 335–350.

VİCKERMAN, R. (2021). Will Covid-19 Put The Public Back İn Public Transport? A UK Perspective. Transport Policy, 103, 95–102.

WOOLF, S. E., & JOUBERT, J. W. (2013). A People- Centered View on Paratransit in South Africa. Cities, 35, 284–293.



How to Cite

Akı Yaman, M., Erbaş, A. E., & Alpkökin, P. (2023). The significance of intermediate public transportation in post-COVID-19 urban transportation planning. JOURNAL OF AWARENESS, 8(3), 321–337.



Research Articles